Globally, approximately 570 million small and medium-sized farms need training in various agricultural fields. However, the delivery of agriculture training faces significant challenges. In some areas, the difficulty in obtaining this training has led to people turning to generative artificial intelligence (AI) models such as ChatGPT to ask questions relating to their agricultural production.
The way that ChatGPT and other models work is that the models are trained on vast amounts of data to learn patterns and relationships between words. This enables the models both to understand language in nuanced ways and to generate answers to a wide range of prompts, which means that ChatGPT can become adapted to specific uses and theoretically provide a comprehensive answer to any question. Researchers supported by the CGIAR's Excellence in Agronomy Initiative and the Digital Innovation Initiative studied the accuracy of Chat GPT-provided information and professional advice in response to queries from African farmers. Tzachor et al (2023) found significant inaccuracies that could potentially lead to poor management and crop losses. The problems with the answers ranged from vagueness to inaccuracy.
I became curious as to how accurate ChatGPT was with regards to questions relating to California rice and so conducted an informal test of my own. I asked ChatGPT questions relating to California water-seeded rice management to see how accurate the model was.
When queried about the insecticides that are registered for use in California water-seeded rice to control armyworms, ChatGPT responded with 6 insecticides – only one of which (lambda-cy) is used in CA rice systems. The remaining insecticides “recommended” were not used in California, not used for armyworms, or no longer commercially available.
I also asked ChatGPT “How to manage weedy rice in California water-seeded rice fields.” The model returned several paragraphs, with one problematic paragraph reproduced below:
Apply herbicides labeled for controlling weedy rice in water-seeded rice fields. Herbicide options may include products containing penoxsulam, propanil, or other active ingredients specifically targeting weedy rice. It's crucial to follow label instructions carefully and use herbicides at the appropriate timing and application rates to maximize effectiveness and minimize off-target effects.
As evidenced by these examples, ChatGPT is responding with answers that are not accurate and should not be taken as recommendations.